At the end of a group's conversion period, some farmers qualify as PGS-Organic and others do not yet. Problems arise when a group is treated as one block. This episode shows how to handle mixed groups, fix incomplete appraisal histories, and complete the RC's decision correctly.
The short version
- Status is per farmer: a group can have PGS-Organic and PGS-Green members.
- Newer members stay PGS-Green until their own period is complete.
- A missing appraisal year blocks the affected farmers.
- The RC decides within 30 days of the summary sheet.
Mixed Groups Are Normal
Farmers who joined later are still converting, so one group can hold both statuses.
When a farmer joins a group mid-way, their conversion starts on their own date. At the end of the group's first conversion period, the original members may qualify as PGS-Organic while newer members remain PGS-Green.
Qualifies as PGS-Organic
- Full conversion period completed
- Every year appraised and approved
- No major non-compliance
Stays PGS-Green
- Joined later; period not complete
- A year missing from the record
- An open major non-compliance
Fixing an Incomplete Appraisal History
Find the year without an approved appraisal and resolve it with the RC; a missing year cannot simply be filled in later.
- Open the group's appraisal history.Check each season for an uploaded and approved summary sheet.
- Find pending approvals.Where a summary sheet was uploaded but not approved, the RC decides on it.
- Find missing years.Where no appraisal happened, the affected farmers do not have a complete record; ask the RC how their status will be treated.
- Record the outcome.Note which farmers qualify and which do not, with reasons.
Every year of the conversion period needs its own approved peer appraisal. A missing year, not the number of years, is what blocks the upgrade.
Completing the RC's Decision
Check the checkpoints, the land totals and each farmer's status, then decide within 30 days.
- Use the seven checkpoints: meetings, trainings, summary sheet, complaints, RC inspection, past record and any residue result.
- Check the group's total area equals the sum of its farmers' plots.
- Confirm each farmer's status individually.
- Decide within 30 days, or return the decision with reasons.
Illustrative workload. Checking start dates for 10 farmers takes about 15 minutes; a 200-farmer group takes about 5 hours.
Portal screens and messages change from time to time. If an option described here is missing, ask your Regional Council, or the PGS-India Secretariat at the National Centre for Organic and Natural Farming.
Check yourself
Tap an answer to see whether you are right, and why.
A farmer joined a group one year after it started. When the group's first members become PGS-Organic, what is this farmer's status?
- PGS-Organic too
- Still PGS-Green until their own period is complete
- Removed
Conversion runs from each farmer's own start.
How long does the RC have to decide on a group's decision?
- 7 days
- 30 days
- 90 days
Otherwise it is auto-approved and a non-compliance is recorded against the RC.
Remember these things
- Status is decided per farmer.
- Newer members stay PGS-Green.
- Missing years block upgrades.
- Decide within 30 days.
Treating each farmer's record on its own merits keeps group decisions accurate. KrushiFlow validates these fields and submits farmer records to the portal in bulk.